Date Completed: January 25th, 2018
In my opinion the Final Fantasy series peaked during the Playstation One era and has been in a gradual decline since. While I haven’t played XI or XIV (since they are online only) all of the main titles since X have been slightly inferior to the game immediately proceeding it. I had decided long before FFXV was released that if it was not ‘good’ I would officially be hanging up my Final Fantasy hat. So, did the game deliver? Periodically my wife would walk in on me while I played and I’ll let her statements speak for the quality of the game.
“All I’ve ever seen you do in that game is drive around in your car.”
“You’re fishing now! That’s new.”
“They look like a boy band from the 90’s”
“Is that a Cup of Noodles hat? Final Fantasy has finally jumped the shark.”
So the question that must be answered is “Was Final Fantasy XV ‘good’ enough?” The answer is “It’s complicated”.
While playing the game I was constantly irritated by various aspects of the game that I thought were either boring or poorly executed. Most of the game takes place in a vast open area that you traverse by driving around in your car. You don’t have access to controlling the car at first but you can tell your driver where you want to go. If you think a game where you watch other people drive is ‘fun’ you are clearly insane. You do eventually gain control of the car yourself however it still mostly self-pilots and isn’t very much fun to drive.
I also found the combat system to be both boring and frustrating. Combat is performed by holding down either the attack or the defense button. While a button is held down combat is mostly automatic. I rarely felt like I (the player) was necessary for success and that my role in battle could have been fulfilled by a strategically placed rubber-band. The frustrating parts occurred when I’d encounter a critter that would kick my butt and I’d have to figure out what I was doing wrong. I spent some time reading online about the combat system trying to find out if there was something I was missing (There wasn’t). Usually the answer was ‘level up more, die less’. Good advice I suppose.
Final Fantasy games are traditionally very story driven but I found the story to be….suboptimal. The story is broken up awkwardly and it’s clear that some decisions were made with the intention of selling additional content after release. The story as told in the game makes very little sense so I found myself reading supplemental material online to fill in the gaps. It also helped to watch the YouTube animated shorts as well as the Kingsglaive movie (available for an additional fee). Even if you invest the time and the money into all the supplemental material the story is kinda dumb. Beautifully animated though.
I could spend a lot of time complaining about the failings of this game but I should note that I did enjoy playing it enough to stick with it for 80 hours. My three-year-old daughter really enjoyed watching me play and especially enjoyed the characters (Prince Noctis was her favorite). While the game might not do anything particularly well it also doesn’t completely bomb either. If I could put a review on the cover I’d write “Utterly Average”. While average might be considered ‘good’ by some I was hoping for more.
So, am I giving up on Final Fantasy? It’s hard to say. FFXV failed to meet my expectations but if Final Fantasy XVI looks amazing I’m sure I’ll find myself being cautiously optimistic once again.
- Is it fun: Yes – barely
- Score: 5/10
- Length: 80 hours
- System: Playstation 4
- Genre: RPG